Three very completely different outcomes present there’s no assure
Though we’ve had a number of the greatest financial savings charges in years, Premium Bonds stay in style. Though there’s no assure in what you might win, folks hope they could get fortunate and internet massive prizes – particularly if they’ve plenty of money invested.
To get an thought of how that pans out, I requested three folks with the utmost £50,000 saved what they gained in a 12 months. Although your personal state of affairs will differ, it’s a good way to grasp what your likelihood is.
Some articles on the location comprise affiliate hyperlinks, which offer a small fee to assist fund our work. Nonetheless, they gained’t have an effect on the value you pay or our editorial independence. Read more here.
What are Premium Bonds?
Not like a financial savings account the place you get a assured return in your deposits – often called an rate of interest – Premium Bonds as an alternative have a Prize Price.
This appears to be like like an rate of interest, however it truly represents how a lot of the entire invested is given out in prizes. These prizes vary from £25 to £1 million. Here’s more on how they work.
What would you hope to win in a 12 months?
Within the final 12 months, the prize charge has truly modified 3 times, beginning at 4.65%, and happening to 4.4%, earlier than dropping to 4.15% for the newest draw (it’s due to fall again to 4% in January 2025).
- January and February 2024 attracts – 4.65% prize charge
- March to November 2024 attracts – 4.4% prize charge
- December 2024 draw – 4.15%
If you happen to add that each one collectively it offers a mean prize charge of 4.42%. That signifies that somebody with the total £50,000 will hope to get a return of £2,210 in a 12 months.
It’s price noting although that the probability of getting near this charge reduces you probably have much less cash held in PBs as you’ll successfully have fewer entries in to every draw, and subsequently fewer probabilities of successful.
Nonetheless, the prize charge is a helpful shorthand for these with common luck. However would you’ve common luck?
How a lot did £50k win over a 12 months?
A couple of years in the past, when financial savings charges have been notably poor, I had £10,000 in Premium Bonds for a full 12 months. And my expertise in that point was fairly good. I truly beat the then charge of 1%.
However since rates of interest elsewhere have improved I’ve solely had cash in PBs (as I prefer to name them) on and off – successfully these months when the prize charge was respectable, however shifting the money when it was overwhelmed.
Then in the summertime I wrote about some mates who had stored the total £50,000 money in Premium Bonds for a 12 months. We’ll name them saver one, saver two and saver three! Right here’s the entire they gained and their efficient win charge
| July 23-June 24 | Saver 1 | Saver 2 | Saver 3 |
| Whole wins | £1,425.00 | £2,950.00 | £2,225.00 |
| Efficient charges | 2.96% | 6.12% | 4.61% |
Bizarrely, the common of saver one and two virtually matched the returns for saver three, which was virtually the common official prize charge for the 12 months!
So six months on, how have issues modified? That is an replace trying again on the entire 12 months of January to December 2024 for those self same three folks, damaged down month by month.
| Saver 1 | Saver 2 | Saver 3 | |
| January 2024 | £225.00 | £125.00 | £375.00 |
| February 2024 | £50.00 | £25.00 | £50.00 |
| March 2024 | £125.00 | £1,000.00 | £175.00 |
| April 2024 | £50.00 | £0.00 | £125.00 |
| Might 2024 | £200.00 | £275.00 | £175.00 |
| June 2024 | £275.00 | £300.00 | £75.00 |
| July 2024 | £150.00 | £275.00 | £100.00 |
| August 2024 | £0.00 | £200.00 | £200.00 |
| September 2024 | £150.00 | £100.00 | £10,075.00 |
| October 2024 | £250.00 | £1,200.00 | £125.00 |
| November 2024 | £225.00 | £25.00 | £225.00 |
| December 2024 | £150.00 | £150.00 | £50.00 |
| —- | —- | —- | |
| Whole wins | £1,850.00 | £3,675.00 | £11,750.00 |
| Efficient charge | 3.70% | 7.35% | 23.50% |
You possibly can see simply how random it’s. Savers one and two had one month with no wins, whereas saver three had a month with an enormous £10,075.
General, saver one fared worst, getting method under the common prize charge of 4.42% with a poor 3.7% return, whereas saver two knocked it out of the park with a large 7.35% return.
Howevever, each did higher on this interval than the 12 months earlier than, regardless of an virtually an identical common official prize charge!
In the meantime the third saver’s enormous £10,000 prize skewed their efficient charge to 23.5% annual return. Now, in the event you swapped that massive win out for the common of all their different prizes at £150, their common drops down massively to three.65%. That will truly be down on their July 2023 to June 2024 common of 4.61%. Although in fact they did win the massive prize.
Why are the outcomes so completely different?
Neglect the rumours how newer bonds usually tend to win, that older bonds are generally excluded, that bonds which have already gained gained’t win once more and even that individuals outdoors of London are at an obstacle.
These are all myths. Each single bond, new and outdated, throughout the UK, has the very same probability of successful one of many prizes. The one factor within the favour of those savours is which have extra entries due to having extra bonds.
However finally is is simply right down to luck. Saver two was only a lot luckier than saver one, whereas saver three was just a bit luckier than common.
It’s an ideal instance of when somebody wins greater than anticipated, somebody misses out. At it’s most excessive in PBs, that’s proven when somebody wins actually massive and lots of, many individuals win nothing in any respect.
Premium Bonds vs financial savings on £50k
So, we’ve established you might do nicely or you might do badly with Premium Bonds in comparison with the prize charge. However what about in the event you’d as an alternative put the cash in an quick access financial savings account?
If our savers as an alternative had moved their cash from greatest purchase to greatest purchase in that interval (a complete of six transfers), they’d have gotten between 4.85% and 5.2%. The typical rate of interest within the 12 months works out (roughly) as 5.04%, and with £50,000 saved you’d earn a mean of £2,520 in assured curiosity.
That’s higher when in comparison with the common prize charge of 4.42% and winnings of £2,210. After all, everybody will get a special win charge. In our examples, saver one (a return of three.7%) was worse off this 12 months with Premium Bonds, whereas each savers two (7.35%) and three (23.5%) ended up with extra from PBs.
Nonetheless it’s not truly that easy.
Tax on curiosity
First, you might want to account for tax. Premium Bond prizes are tax-free, so there’s no curiosity on the return. Outdoors of PBs or ISAs, you’re taxed, however you possibly can’t simply deduct the tax charge from the rate of interest to get a correct comparability.
You additionally have to think about the personal savings allowance. Right here’s what placing the total £50,000 in to financial savings on the common charge would actually return (bear in mind the Premium Bond complete is common luck).
| Quantity | Price | Tax-free | Whole curiosity after tax | Equal charge after PSA & tax |
| Premium Bonds | 4.42% | All | £2,210.00 | 4.42% |
| Non taxpayer | 5.04% | All | £2,520.00 | 5.04% |
| Primary charge taxpayer (20%) | 5.04% | £1,000 | £2,216.00 | 4.43% |
| Increased charge taxpayer (40%) | 5.04% | £500 | £1,711.00 | 3.42% |
| Further charge taxpayer (45%) | 5.04% | £0 | £1,386.00 | 2.77% |
So on this occasion, it nonetheless seems that Premium Bonds would have given similar return for primary charge tax payers, and the most effective return over this era for each increased and extra charge tax payers. I do know that my pal saver one is a better charge payer, so in actuality his 3.81% Premium Bond return is healthier than what he’d have gotten elsewhere after tax.
Get the most effective of our cash saving content material each Thursday, straight to your inbox
+ Get a £20 Quidco bonus (new members solely). More details
A mixture of PBs, ISAs and financial savings
Nonetheless, in actuality, a greater mixture could possibly be to place £20,000 into regular financial savings at a 5% to earn £1,000 of tax free curiosity (or £10,000 to earn £500 for a better charge taxpayer), and one other £20,000 into an ISA at the same charge, after which put the remainder into Premium Bonds.
Sadly we are able to’t ever calculate the true returns right here because it’s doubtless that somebody with £30,000 or £40,000 in PBs will win lower than somebody with £50,000 there. Nonetheless, if we maintain the common prize charge at 4.38%, and mix it with the opposite tax-free returns, it might appear like this.
| Financial savings in PBs after PSA and PBs | Price | Prizes | Curiosity elsewhere | Whole curiosity | Equal charge |
| £10,000.00 (primary charge taxpayer) | 4.42% | £442.00 | £2,000.00 | £2,442.00 | 4.88% |
| £20,000.00 (increased charge taxpayer) | 4.42% | £884.00 | £1,500.00 | £2,384.00 | 4.77% |
Doubtless, the mixture is giving the most effective general returns on cash – for somebody with common luck.
And if we put in a nasty (although not worst case) state of affairs the place the prize returns have been simply 1.5% on the extra money in Premium Bonds, you’d nonetheless match returns after tax for a primary charge taxpayer who put every part in easy-access financial savings and beat it as a better charge taxpayer.
| Financial savings in PBs after PSA and PBs | Price | Prizes | Curiosity elsewhere | Whole curiosity | Equal charge |
| £10,000.00 (primary charge taxpayer) | 1.5% | £150 | £2,000.00 | £2,150 | 4.3% |
| £20,000.00 (increased charge taxpayer) | 1.5% | £300 | £1,500.00 | £1,800 | 3.6% |
So, in the event you’re after a assured return slightly than depend on luck, you’re nonetheless higher off utilizing your PSA and ISAs allowances first.
After all, further charge taxpayers solely get the ISA tax-free returns, in order that they’d be higher off with PBs over different financial savings with financial savings of this measurement.
Incomes curiosity on the prizes
One other issue to think about is you possibly can’t reinvest prizes into PBs if you have already got the total £50k saved. Which suggests our three savers all (hopefully) moved their winnings right into a excessive paying account to maintain incomes, maybe as a lot as 7% via regular saver, then they’d earn extra on high – even when tax was doubtlessly due on that.
Are Premium Bonds price it?
Andy’s evaluation
As demonstrated, there’s no assure you’ll do nicely with Premium Bonds. Regardless of two of our savers outperforming different financial savings merchandise with their bonds, I nonetheless suppose getting a assured financial savings charge that beats the prize charge is healthier than the slim probability of successful massive. Particularly you probably have smaller quantities the place your probabilities of successful enormously lower.
However, there are occasions once they’re price a shot. Extra related to now could be for these with giant sums saved up. If you happen to’re already filling your private financial savings allowance (or in the event you don’t get one) and have maxed out the annual ISA allowance (maybe in shares and shares slightly than money), Premium Bonds could be a good possibility.
And as I skilled earlier than the bottom charge hikes boosted financial savings charges, there could be events the place Premium Bonds internet you extra cash. That was particularly the case when financial savings charges have been under 1%. Nonetheless, it’s unlikely we’ll return to these ranges any time quickly, if in any respect.
